I recently read how a photographer didn't like photobooks that showed pictures that "do not take you anywhere," didn't like Friedlander books 'cause they were more catalogs than photobooks. Got it! Guess he wouldn't be much up on the Bechers, or typologies in general. And while I certainly appreciate the narrative, story telling of more journalistic photographic essays, or even the purely fictional narratives of a photographer like Les Krims or Duane Michals, I also appreciate photobooks that are, in essence, portable gallery shows, catalogs- pictures of the same thing... more or less. They all serve slightly different purposes, as do styles of: music, fashion, literature, etc.
There's also something to be said of the design of photobooks that just present and highlight the photographs themselves without any added artifice, as well as more decorative books that are veritable art objects in and of themselves, or supply informative historical or geographical accompaniments- as long as they serve to enhance the overall experience, and don't interfere with the main meal itself.*
That said, I most definitely do not appreciate books with scattershot presentations of photos in various sizes in various positions of the page that leave me guessing where I'll have to turn my head or shift my vision and focus to view the next image. I'd much rather embrace: well centered, no nonsense Teutonic, picture in the middle repetitiveness that let the pictures speak for themselves, rather than be forcibly engaged in aberrant spatial acrobatics. And who's a fan of double truck images that don't completely fold out, creating significant image and content loss? That said, I do appreciate: the occasional blank page, size differentials that help emphasize and pace, as well as accordion style stitching or image foldouts (love the foldouts).
Just a small meditation and a few notes of appreciation and criticism as I formulate my next self publishing venture...
*Rob Stephenson's next book will feature mix and match pages of twin homes in New York; at first, I thought it downright silly, then saw a mockup that demonstrated how it would look and work- interactive, engaging and... fun!





